Watch videos with subtitles in your language, upload your videos, create your own subtitles! Click here to learn more on "how to Dotsub"

experiment with bucket

0 (0 Likes / 0 Dislikes)
Now I want to revisit the situation that you are on the end of my string and I'm going to swirl you around. Earlier, I swirled you around like this this and you didn't like it and I don't blame you because you got dizzy. Now I'm going to rotate you like this. You may like that better. Maybe not. And so, whether you like it or not I'm going to twirl you around and here you are. This is the circle. There's a string-- you're here. Here's the string and there you are. You have a certain velocity. Your velocity is in this direction is a certain distance to the center, R. And so you need a certain centripetal acceleration to go around in that curve. So you need a centripetal acceleration a of c--which can take the v squared divided by r, if you like that. This is the magnitude of that v. Now follow me very closely. Just imagine this number happens to be exactly 9.8. I can always do that. Where is this person going to get the push or the pull from this centripetal acceleration? Does the string have to pull on it? No because there's always gravity and gravity gives you an acceleration of 9.8 meters per second squared. So the string says, "Tough luck, I don't have to do anything. "Gravity provides me with the 9.8 meters per second squared that I required." Now I'm going to swing you faster, so the v will go up and so the centripetal acceleration will go up. The string will say "Aha! I'm going to pull now on this person "because the gravitational acceleration alone is not enough-- I need some extra pull." So the string is going to tighten and pull on you. And I say, "Hello, there, in what direction is gravity?" And you say, "Gravity is in this direction." Why? Because you feel the string is pulling on you in this direction, so you experience gravity there. Now comes the question, how real is this? This is very, very real. It is so real that if I took a bucket of water instead of you...and here is the bucket of water. I attached to the bucket a rope. I swing it around, and I swing it around such that the centripetal acceleration is substantially larger than 9.8 so the string is definitely going to pull if you were the water, and I asked you, "Where is gravity?" you would say the gravitational direction is in this direction and so the water will say, "Okay, fine, then this will be my surface and I want to go in this direction." But the water can't go in that direction so it will just stay there. So I could swing this thing around if I do it fast enough-- so fast that the acceleration at this point here must be larger than 9.8-- the water will stay up while the bucket is upside down. How fast should I rotate it? Well, let's put in some simple numbers. I have here this bucket and let's say that this is about one meter. Let's round some numbers off. So R is about one meter. And I want v squared over R I want that to be larger than 9.8-- let's just call it 10. So that means v has to be larger than about 3.2 meters per second. The time to go around is two pi R divided by this velocity so this time to go around, then, has to be six... has to be less than two seconds. So if I swing this around in less than two seconds I will be okay. Now, I realize that the speed when I move this thing around is not constant everywhere. That's very difficult to do that, because of gravity. But it's close enough to get an idea. So if I rotate this faster than in two seconds when the bucket is upside-down if physics works, the water should not fall out. So let us fill this with water. There we go. I'm always nervous about this. Um, let's first look at the centrifuge. We have to see whether the centrifuge has done its job. So let's look at what this tube... I think it was tube number four. Oh, yeah! Very clear is now the liquid and you see the white stuff here on the side. It's not too easy for you to see, really. I put my hand under here. Maybe some of you can see some white stuff but it's no longer milk-- really a clear liquid. Here you see some white stuff here but it's also on the side. You can actually see it here. You see the white stuff because this was the direction of gravity so it ended up here and there's some here . It is completely clear. You see the white stuff? So that's the way that you can separate the silver chloride. So now we come to this daredevil, daredevil experiment. And we're going to see whether we can fool the water and make the water think that gravity is not in this direction but in this direction. Now, you're doing the right thing, there. I don't blame you at all. Okay... There we go! You see the water is completely fooled and notice that I go around substantially faster than in two seconds. And the water, when it's up there just thinks that gravity is towards the ceiling. Physics works. Now, who is going to do this for me, too? Please, someone should try this. You think you can do it? Come on, try it. In the worst case, it will be a disaster. Okay, get some feel for it, but before you do it make sure that I'm out of the way. But first swing it a little and don't hold it too close to you because I don't want you to get hurt Larger swing, larger, larger. Now you get some feel for it. Go for it, now! Yeah, faster! That was very good.

Video Details

Duration: 8 minutes and 41 seconds
Country: Hungary
Language: English
Views: 93
Posted by: karpatj on May 11, 2011

Walter Lewin experiment

Caption and Translate

    Sign In/Register for Dotsub to translate this video.